
In one of my all time favorite Mr. Show sketches, a character played by Bob Odenkirk is hooked up to a polygraph machine and four or five people, one of which is played by David Cross, are barraging him with questions in order to test his integrity and honesty as a potential future employee of a company that remains unnamed until the end of the sketch. During his interview, the shirt-sleeves-and-neck-tie-wearing interviewers begin to grimly interrogate Odenkirk’s character about any potential history he may have had with drug use, asking him if he has done a series of increasingly severe drugs (alcohol, marijuana, coke, and right on up the list). By the time the interviewers get to crack cocaine on this list—and Odenkirk’s character says, yes, in fact, he has smoked crack—they break from their roles as objective, scientific, suited men who are administering a polygraph test and excitedly ask Bob Odenkirk’s character what it was like to smoke crack, with the implication that they think it’s really cool that he’s done this drug. Odenkirk’s character then coolly answers something to the effect of “Ehh, It’s crack; it gets you real high.”
And, of course, the point of Odenkirk’s character’s too-cool response in this scene is that the stimuli you consume, no matter how intense that stimuli may be, sometimes has the exact effect you anticipate. In essence, smoking crack, according to the character, will be underwhelming for the new user in that it will get you exactly as high as you expect it to; no more, no less.
Having found Mr. Cross’s book, I Drink for A Reason, on sale in (of all places) Urban Outfitters, I grabbed it, shelled out the five bucks, and eagerly awaited to have a similar response as his former co-star’s recreational-crack-smoking character—thinking this book will do nothing more or less than just hit the spot. It won’t blow my mind, but I won’t want to run it through a paper shredder, page-by-page, in an act of misdirected revenge on its author. (See: my graduate school experience with The Wasteland. It involved fire and a scorched Norton Critical Edition.)

Thankfully, I Drink for A Reason ended up doing exactly what I thought: perfecctly meeting my expectations. At times it had me laughing out loud in public; at other times it was trying way too hard to accuse the “average American” of being a moronic philistine; at times it was childishly funny, and at other times it was childish and unfunny. In short, I Drink for A Reason is representative of Mr. Cross’s other work: sometimes it’s perfect in its biting insight and other times its agonizingly cute and unfocused in its sarcastic aggression.
For a comedian who prides himself on his political awareness and on his being informed about religious hypocrisy, American news media, and civil procedure, I found the funniest stuff in the book (and generally in Cross’s career) to be his less heady stuff, specifically the material that dealt with the world of entertainment. His rant about Larry the Cable Guy, for example, is Cross at his best: informed, entertaining, and unforgiving to his subject. If anything, this book is worth picking up for the frequent gags at the expense of Jim Belushi (which comprises about 45% of the book).
As for Mr. Cross’s repeatedly vilifying Fox News and Rupert Murdoch, I feel like this is not only boring, but too easy for him. I get it: News Corp is bad. Just make fun of Dane Cook some more, please.
If you’re a fan of David Cross’s other material, I would recommend picking this book up, but check your expectations at the book store check out counter. Will it blow your mind? No, but it will keep you occupied until the Arrested Development movie finally gets made.